The Lamp Post Inn: Your Destination for Italian-American Delights in Sussex, NJ

Food was amazing, great ambience, wish we would’ve asked the waitresses name, she was lovely. Great menu also, cannot say enough n good things!

I love this place and will be going back there. Next time I go to New Jersey. As soon as we sat down, we were brought an Italian bread. Warm oh my goodness so good. Bobby had a calzone. I ordered a meatball sub. I only could eat half of. It was so good though. And if you look at the picture of the calzone, it was huge. The waitress was so sweet. Just very, very nice people all the way around I can’t wait to go back there.

We have been going to the Lamp Post for years. Yes there have been times when the bartender/wait staff have disappeared. We have a friend (Ed) who makes the pizza and it is a home run everytime he makes our pizza. They do have other menu items that are very good. We have had a bad meal recently only once, and I believe it was during the transition of changing owners. We had the pleasure of meeting the new owner (Brian) the other day and I think once he works out the kinks, no one will have to worry about the missing staff member. Please give this new owner a chance. Their food is 99 percent spot on.

I had an amazing dining experience at this establishment. It was my first time here, and although there was a wait and it was quite busy, the staff managed great. Our food was excellent, especially the grilled cheese, which was exceptionally well made. However, the view was even better. Special thanks to the beautiful busboy I had a massive crush on throughout dinner. I miss you already king

Celebrated my son Alex’s birthday this evening along with my family. The service and the food was delicious. Our waitress was very nice and promptly served us. The calamari appetizer was outstanding. The 16oz steak was delicious. Strongly recommend this restaurant.

Best French onion soup I ever had. I feel low key disappointed when I go to other restaurants and try their French onion soup and it can’t be compared with the one from the lamp post inn. The staff is very friendly too. They will make you feel special.

Absolutely glad we decided to stop here. The atmosphere was fantastic and we really enjoyed the live music. We ran a 31 mile race earlier in the day and wanted a good burger. The burgers were huge, flavorful and the bun was tasty too. Loved the fries. Great service and great food.

My husband and I live near the Lamppost and have for the past 25 years. We have always frequented the place as our local spot. But recently the food and service has really improved! I cannot tell you how wonderful we were treated there tonight. If you haven't tried it in a while try it again for the first time. We introduced ourselves to Brian the new owner and wished him the best of luck......he seems like a hard worker and very dedicated to making his own success! Good luck and great job!